I was recently reading “Style – The Basics of Clarity and Grace” by Joseph M. Williams for an English class. The author states using the word “he” as a generic pronoun could become a problem of biased language. “Common sense demands that we not gratuitously offend reader, but if we reject he as a generic pronoun because it’s biased and they because some readers consider it ungrammatical, we are left with several bad choices. We can try a first person we. Some writers use one. For years to come, we’ll have a problem with singular generic pronouns, and to some readers, any solution will be awkward. I suspect that eventually we will accept the plural they as a correct singular.” (p. 24- 25 – Style by Joseph M. Williams)
I don’t know how many times I have seen children’s magazines for parents with articles that use both he and she to describe a toddlers growth and so forth. I just accept it because they are trying to write an article that encompasses both genders without using a they. I have had instructors tell me to be more specific when I use a generic pronoun and it seems to help the story line. Replacing a they with a different description helps too. I don’t know if I agree totally with Williams about pronouns being biased. I don’t get offended when I read articles that just use he.
So I guess the lesson here is seeing what works for you and your audience.
Leave a Reply